Why are my scones crumbly when cooked? A baking mystery solved!

Scones are a delicious pastry that can be enjoyed for breakfast or as a snack.

However, many people struggle with getting them to be nice and fluffy when they are cooked.

In this blog post, we will explore the mystery of why scones often turn out crumbly, and provide some tips on how to fix the issue!

How do I make my scones less crumbly?

The addition of cheese grated to the scone will almost never be wrong.

It is mostly fat with a very small amount of liquid. So, it serves similar functions to butter you put in your scone.

It can help keep it soft and crumbly. For most scone recipes, you can include grated cheese, without altering the texture.

Other ways to make scones less crumbly is by using buttermilk, adding an extra egg yolk or swapping out some of the flour for cornstarch.

When it comes to baking, fat equals flavor and moisture. So, if you want a more moist and flavorful scone, opt for one that has butter, cream and/or eggs in the recipe.

Lastly, don’t overmix the batter. Mix just until the ingredients are combined. Overmixing will result in a tougher texture.

Why don’t my scones rise high?

First, ensure that you’re using fresh baking soda that was open less than six months from now.

If you are kneading the dough too long the scones won’t get as high.

In addition, adding more flour prevents your dough from growing to the same height, so just dust lightly.

Lastly, make sure your oven is preheated before baking.

If you find that your scones aren’t rising as high as you’d like, there are a few things you can check.

First, ensure that you’re using fresh baking soda. Baking soda that’s been open for more than six months might not be as effective.

Second, try not to over-knead the dough. If you knead it too long, the scones won’t rise as high.

Third, be careful not to add too much flour when you’re dusting your work surface. Adding too much flour will prevent the dough from rising to its full height.

Lastly, make sure your oven is preheated before you bake the scones. If it isn’t preheated, the scones won’t rise as much as they should.

Should scones be wet or dry?

The texture of scone dough ought to be very wet and sticky since this loose texture is able in creating the lightest and fluffy texture after baking.

The dryer your dough is and the less capacity for the dough to rise when baked and the more dense the scones will be.

Scones are meant to be eaten with your hands and not with a fork, so the final product should have a soft crumble.

If you want a firmer exterior, you can brush on some milk or an egg wash before baking.

The addition of wet ingredients like buttermilk or cream will also result in a moister scone.

If you find that your dough is too dry, add in more wet ingredient until the desired texture is achieved.

The key to making scones is to not over mix the dough since this will make for tough scones.

Mix just until the flour is moistened and then shape into rounds before baking. And there you have it!

The perfect scone recipe for light and fluffy scones every time.

How do you make scones rise higher?

Similar to cinnamon rolls, placing your scones side-by-side and touching them assists in making the scones rise equally and then higher.

Since heat causes scones to rise when they are placed side-by-side the scones will be made to rise upwards, not downwards.

Also, make sure your oven is preheated because if it’s not hot enough when you put the scones in, they may fall.

Lastly, don’t overwork the dough or handle it too much because this will make them tough and result in less rise.

If you follow these tips, your scones should have no problem rising to new heights!

If you want your scones to be extra light and fluffy, add an extra tablespoon or two of baking powder to the recipe.

This will help them rise even higher! Just be careful not to add too much or they may end up tasting a bit bitter.

Another way to get ultra light and fluffy scones is by using self-rising.

How can I tell if my scones are cooked?

Bake Scones in a 425degF baking oven at 18 or 23 mins or until they’re a mild golden color. Don’t overbake them; the scones that are dark will be dry.

Open one to check for crookedness: the inside isn’t likely to appear wet or doughy but it should be soft and moist.

If you’re not sure whether the scones are done, err on the side of undercooking because you can always pop them back in the oven for a minute or two.

But if they’re overbaked, there’s no going back!

If you have a baking stone or unglazed quarry tile, use it: the scones will brown better and cook more evenly.

If not, bake them on an ungreased baking sheet. You can line the baking sheet with parchment paper if you want to make cleanup easier.

Scones are best eaten on the day they’re made but you can store them in an airtight container for a day or two.

To reheat, wrap in foil and place in a 350degF oven for about 12 minutes.

Scones are best eaten on the day they’re made but you can store them in an airtight container for a day or two.

Why are my scones flat and hard?

Inadvertently making use of an all-purpose (plain) flour instead that of self-rising (self-raising) flour or including the rising agent in plain flour may result in flat Scones to become flat.

Make sure your ingredient are in good condition. This includes baking soda, yeast along with baking powder.

If the mixture starts to fizzed it means that baking soda is in good condition.

If you are using yeast, make sure it is still active by mixing it with a little lukewarm water and sugar. The mixture should become frothy within a few minutes.

Baking powder on the other hand, usually has a longer shelf life. However, to be sure that it is still active, add a teaspoon of baking powder to a cup of water.

The mixture should fizzed immediately. If not, then it’s time to buy some new baking powder!

Scones could also become hard if they are overcooked. Be sure to follow the recipe cooking times closely.

Do not be tempted to cook them for longer in order to achieve a deeper golden color as this will result in dry Scones. And there

How do you know when cheese scones are cooked?

Make use of the top of your fingers to accomplish this. Inject a toothpick or skewer inside the scone.

If it’s clear, the scone is cooked. If it’s a mess with dough the scones will require some time to cook.

If you want to be doubly certain, then use an oven thermometer. They ought to read 200°F when they are fully cooked.

Scones are done when the tops are golden brown and a toothpick inserted into the center of the scone comes out clean.

If you find that your scones are browning too quickly, cover them with foil for the last few minutes of baking.

And there you have it! Now you know how to tell when cheese scones are cooked and you can enjoy them fresh from the oven any time!

How do you revive stale scones?

Defrost them in their containers for a couple of hours at temperatures of room temperature.

Scones taste much better warm than cold so you can reheat Scones in a preheated oven at 160oC/325degF/140oC/gas 3 for 5 minutes or microwave for 10-20 seconds however baking in the oven is the most efficient method.

Scones are best eaten on the day of baking however if you have some leftover, store them in an airtight container and they will be fine for a day or two.

If they start to dry out, simply pop them in the oven for a couple of minutes until warmed through. Serve with butter, clotted cream and jam. Enjoy!

The scones should be nicely defrosted by now so go ahead and preheat your oven to 160oC/325degF/140oC/gas mark three.

Once heated, put the scones in for five minutes or until warmed through completely. Take them out and enjoy with some butter, clotted cream and jam!

If you find that your scones have gone a little stale, don’t worry! There are plenty of ways to revive them and enjoy them once again.

Just follow these simple steps and you’ll be enjoying delicious scones in no time.

First, defrost the scones in their containers for a couple of hours at room temperature.

This will help to bring back some of the moisture that they may have lost.

What does butter do in scones?

Butter imparts a more pronounced flavor. Milk The amount of milk or liquid that is used will depend on the final texture you want.

For instance substituting the half-milk with cream results in an scone with a thicker texture, when using buttermilk, it creates the scone lighter and more bread-like scone.

The fats in the butter also help to tenderize the gluten proteins in flour which results in a more delicate and flaky texture.

While you can use oil in scones, it does not provide the same flavor or texture as butter.

If you do need to use a dairy-free alternative, look for vegan margarines that contain high amounts of vegetable oils.

These will usually be found near the regular butter in your grocery store. Avoid using shortening as it will make your scones dense and heavy.

When substituting fat, always use the same amount called for in the recipe.

If you want a truly light and airy scone, make sure to use cold ingredients straight from the fridge (butter, milk, etc).

Room temperature ingredients will produce a denser scone. Also, be careful not to overwork the dough as this will result in a tough final product.

Finally, make sure your baking powder is fresh! Baking powder that’s been sitting on the shelf for awhile won’t be as effective and could result in a less than perfect scone.


Scones are a delicious British treat that can be enjoyed with tea or coffee.

However, sometimes they can turn out crumbly when cooked.

This baking mystery has been solved! The reason your scones turned out crumbly is because of the high fat content in the recipe.

To make sure your scones turn out fluffy and moist, try using a low-fat recipe next time you bake them. Thanks for reading and happy baking!

Click to rate this post!
[Total: 0 Average: 0]